Small batch baked goods · Oak Creek, Wisconsin

Kind Words

from the neighbors

Notes people have sent after pickup. Every one is real, unedited, and from someone who’s enjoyed baked goods from my kitchen.

“Sara is the most thoughtful baker! She is passionate about her baked goods and makes everything with high quality ingredients and precision. I have yet to try anything she's baked I don't love.”
ErikaSep 5, 2026
14
Notes since 2026

Recent notes

Newest first
Pumpkin spice chocolate chip cake Thank your mom Sara for her suggestion to make this cake and offer it. Moist…just the right amount of sweet with the chocolate chips and the spices were spot on….another winner….i hope others will try it….they won’t be disappointed.
SharonOct 17, 2026
Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Chip Cake
Sara replied

Aww Sharon I'm so happy you enjoyed the cake! It's one of my favorites too! 😋

The Kanelbullar Swedish cinnamon buns are incredible. Just the right amount of sweet and pairs amazing with a cup of coffee on a brisk fall day.
JulieSep 27, 2026
Kanelbullar - Swedish Cinnamon Buns
Sara replied

I 100% agree! So glad you loved them!

I had the brownies. They are so fudgy and rich. I’ve known Sara for quite some time and have NEVER been disappointed with anything she bakes!
EllenSep 16, 2026
Sara replied

So happy you enjoyed the brownies!

I’m not big on sweets but these are the best chocolate chip cookies I’ve ever had. I ate all 3 at once!
JourdanSep 5, 2026
Sara replied

I’m so glad you love the cookies!

Little delicious bites of goodness. And I could actually taste the almond flavor which I love. You nailed it Sara.
SharonOct 11, 2026
Financiers - Browned Butter Almond Cakes
Sara replied

You just made my day!

I love how pretty everything is arranged in the boxes! :)
HeidiOct 5, 2026
Pumpkin Spiced Muffins · Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies
Sara replied

Thank you Heidi!

The chocolate chip cookies are to die for! Perfectly chewy, chocolatey, and with just the right amount of sea salt. My new addiction!
JulieSep 21, 2026
Sara replied

I’m so thrilled you enjoyed them! 🍪

Sara's gourmet taste totally shines in her baking! Her items are classics, with an added flair that always keeps me eager for her next creation. The browned butter really elevated the complexity and is easily among the best muffins I've ever had!
ErickaSep 6, 2026
Sara replied

This is so wonderful to hear—thank you!

Bakery quality, sophisticated muffins, with great flavor! Will definitely be a repeat customer!!
HeidiSep 4, 2026
Sara replied

Thank you Heidi! I'm so glad you enjoyed them!

Financiers - Browned Butter Almond Cakes. Just had some of these with coffee. Amazing. Sara is an amazing home baker!
EllenOct 10, 2026
Sara replied

I'm so happy you enjoyed them!

Sara your muffins were beyond delicious….perfectly balanced with it not being overly sweet….moist and crumbly all in a good way….i did’t even need peanut butter to add that little something some muffins need. You’ll get no negative feedback from me….11 stars….
SharonOct 4, 2026
Browned Butter Chocolate Chunk Muffins
Sara replied

Thank you so much for taking the time to share this Sharon!

Pickup was great! And Browned Butter Chocolate Chunk muffins were amazing!
EllenSep 21, 2026
Browned Butter Chocolate Chunk Muffins
Sara replied

I'm so glad you love those muffins!

I loved the amount of salt on top of the chocolate chip cookies, it was perfect! So chewy and delicious!
DevinSep 6, 2026
Sara replied

So glad they were a hit!

Ordered from us before?

Tell me how it went. A few days after pickup I send one short email asking the same thing, and that is where most of these came from. You get to say whether yours goes on this page or stays between us.

Share a note